Titanium cutting boards are thin sheets of metal sold as a clean, durable alternative to wood and plastic. The listings stress what metal does well: it does not absorb liquid and it resists corrosion. What they tend to leave out is what a metal surface does to a knife. In independent testing, metal boards dulled knives far faster than wood, they were loud under the blade, and some boards labeled titanium turned out not to be titanium at all.

Here is what a titanium board is, what the tests found, and how it compares with a bamboo board on the points that matter in a home kitchen.

What a titanium board is

Titanium cutting boards are flat metal sheets, and some have a bent lip along one edge that hooks over the counter. They are thin. When America’s Test Kitchen bought five metal boards for a review, every one measured under 2 millimeters thick.

Titanium itself has real strengths. It is as strong as some steels but less dense, it has excellent resistance to corrosion, and it is considered one of the most biocompatible metals, which has given it a range of medical uses. Those properties are true of the metal. Whether they make it a good cutting surface is a separate question.

What happens to the knife edge

This is the point the marketing tends to skip.

America’s Test Kitchen cut parsley, onions, butternut squash and tomatoes on stainless steel and titanium boards, recording knife sharpness with an industrial sharpness tester before and after each test. Every time the testers cut on any of the metal boards, the knife dulled dramatically, and they saw no significant difference between stainless and titanium. By contrast, the identical knife assigned to a wooden board stayed in near-new condition throughout. Their conclusion was that metal boards are not more durable or easier to clean than other boards, and that they will damage your knives.

Prudent Reviews ran a separate test, sharpening knives to nearly identical edges and then dulling them with 300 rocking cuts and 300 straight chops on each surface and measuring the edges with a sharpness tester. Titanium was by far the worst of the materials tested, and stainless steel was second to last. Plastic, wood and rubber were all much gentler on the edge.

The reason is not complicated. A knife edge is a very thin strip of steel. On wood or bamboo, the edge sinks a fraction into the surface at the bottom of the cut and stops there. On metal, it meets a surface that does not yield, and the thin edge takes the impact instead.

Do that a few hundred times and the edge rolls and loses its bite.

Scratches, and what is in them

A metal board is not scratch-proof. America’s Test Kitchen saw knife scratches on every board it tested, with the most on the one board it judged to be real titanium. As the review put it, every scratch is metal shaved off the board, and potentially ingested.

The scratches also undercut the idea of a surface that stays spotless. After hand washing with hot, soapy water, the testers found the metal surfaces still showed dark splotches where food had been cut.

Is it really titanium?

Labels are not a reliable guide. Of the three boards America’s Test Kitchen bought that were sold as titanium, only one was. The testers calculated each board’s density and found that the other two could not be titanium; the review identifies them as stainless steel, and notes that real titanium usually comes as an alloy, mixed with other metals.

Two practical checks follow from that:

  • Weight. Titanium is less dense than steel, so a real titanium board should weigh less than a steel board of the same size. A heavy “titanium” board is worth questioning.
  • Color. A gold tone on metal can be titanium nitride, a coating used on cutting tools such as drill bits and as a gold-colored decorative finish. A coating tells you nothing about the metal underneath it.

When a listing does not name the grade or alloy, ask the seller before buying.

Noise and grip

Metal is loud under a knife. America’s Test Kitchen described knives clacking unpleasantly against the hard surfaces, and a bench scraper sometimes screeched. In the Prudent Reviews test, titanium and stainless steel boards were the loudest by a wide margin.

Metal is also slick. The test kitchen’s boards slid, spun or rocked unless a damp paper towel went underneath. A board that moves under a knife is a safety issue, not only an annoyance.

What a titanium board is good for

If you already own one, a thin, non-absorbent, corrosion-resistant sheet has uses that do not involve a knife. It can serve as a tray for carrying food to the grill or a place to stage ingredients for a stir-fry. America’s Test Kitchen found that none of its boards rusted or showed damage after being left wet overnight, or after a night under fresh lemon slices.

Used that way, as a tray rather than a cutting board, the metal’s strengths finally count.

Where bamboo differs

A bamboo board works on the opposite principle. Bamboo yields slightly under the blade, the way wood does, so the edge settles into the surface instead of striking it. On the Janka hardness scale bamboo measures about 1,380 lbf, close to hard maple, which is firm enough to resist deep gouging without being hard on an edge the way glass, stone and steel are. Is bamboo too hard for your knives goes into the numbers.

Bamboo is also dense and less porous than many traditional hardwoods, so it absorbs fewer liquids and odors. The care is ordinary, the same as for any wooden board: wash it by hand with hot, soapy water, dry it on edge and oil it when the surface looks pale. Like every wooden board, it is never put in the dishwasher. How to care for a bamboo cutting board sets out the routine.

The WONAMU. bamboo cutting board is 12 by 9 inches, a size that sits flat on a standard counter, with a perimeter juice groove for tomatoes, fruit and resting meat. For a wider look at the alternatives, glass, silicone or wood compares the other hard and soft surfaces, and why restaurants use plastic cutting boards covers the commercial side.

The short version

Titanium is a strong, light, corrosion-resistant metal, and a titanium sheet can serve as a tray. As a cutting board, it fails the test that matters most to a cook: independent testing found that metal boards, titanium included, dulled knives dramatically, while wood kept the edge sharp. They are loud, they slide without a towel underneath, they scratch, and a “titanium” label does not guarantee titanium. For the cutting itself, choose a surface that gives under the blade, such as bamboo or wood.

❋

WONAMU. makes a bamboo cutting board designed for daily prep, 12 × 9 inches, bamboo, with a perimeter juice groove. Available on Amazon.

Designed by nature.